News & Guides
Tips & GuidesEssays 6 min read

Writing Supplemental Essays That Don't Sound Generic

How to answer 'Why us,' 'Why this major,' and community prompts with specifics a reader cannot find in a brochure.

The swap test

Replace the college's name in your draft with a rival's. If the essay still reads fine, you have written nothing. Every 'Why us' needs at least two details that exist only at that school — a specific course number, a lab, a sequence, a tradition — and one sentence explaining what you would do with it.

Where to find real specifics

  • The course catalog, not the admissions page.
  • Faculty pages of two professors whose work you can describe in a sentence.
  • The student newspaper for what students actually argue about.
  • Club rosters and research programs open to undergraduates.

Structure for a 150-word answer

  • One sentence naming the concrete thing you want.
  • Two sentences of evidence that you already do this.
  • One sentence on what you would contribute, not just consume.

Reuse without recycling

Keep a master document of your specifics, sorted by school. Reuse structure across applications; never reuse the school-specific sentences. The fastest rejection in the pile is another college's name left in the draft.

Keep going